You find overlapping security tools by mapping each tool to the capability it provides, then comparing that map against the Microsoft licenses you already pay for. Where a license covers the same capability, check whether it is turned on and configured before you decide which tool stays.
The best time to do this is before a renewal, while you still have room to choose.
The Accelerynt Security Tool ROI Assessment does this in six weeks, ending with a keep, kill or optimize decision for every tool and a 90-day consolidation plan.
Where to look first
- Identity. A separate identity provider or MFA service running alongside Microsoft Entra ID.
- Endpoint. A second endpoint detection and response platform next to Microsoft Defender for Endpoint.
- Email security. A separate email gateway that overlaps Microsoft Defender for Office 365.
- SIEM. A second SIEM alongside Microsoft Sentinel, with some logs collected twice.
Why does tool overlap matter beyond cost?
Paying twice for the same capability is the visible cost. The less visible one is that every extra tool adds an integration to maintain, and fragile integrations make security changes slow and risky.
Our post Trapped in the Vendor Web describes a client whose separate identity tools turned every small policy change into days of compatibility checks. After the client consolidated onto Microsoft Entra ID, policy changes went through without that friction and compliance evidence improved.
What security does Microsoft 365 E5 include?
If you license Microsoft 365 E5, you may already own capabilities you also buy elsewhere. The table lists security products Microsoft includes in E5 and the kind of overlap to look for.
| Capability | Included in Microsoft 365 E5 | Overlap to check for |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and access | Microsoft Entra ID P2 | A separate identity provider or MFA service |
| Endpoint protection | Microsoft Defender for Endpoint P2 | A second EDR or antivirus platform |
| Email security | Microsoft Defender for Office 365 P2 | A separate email security gateway |
| Identity threat detection | Microsoft Defender for Identity | A separate tool that watches Active Directory for attacks |
| Cloud app visibility | Microsoft Defender for Cloud Apps | A separate shadow IT discovery or cloud app security tool |
| Data protection | Microsoft Purview Data Loss Prevention and Information Protection | A separate DLP or data classification tool |
How do you find overlapping security tools?
- Inventory every tool and contract. List each security tool with its cost, owner and renewal date, along with the Microsoft licenses you hold.
- Map each tool to a capability. Group tools by what they do, such as identity, endpoint, email or SIEM, so overlaps show up side by side.
- Compare usage with licensed capacity. Check how much of each tool is actually used, and whether the matching Microsoft capability is turned on and configured.
- Decide keep, kill or optimize. For each overlap, decide whether to keep the tool, retire it or configure the Microsoft capability you already own.
- Plan around renewal dates. Sequence changes by contract end dates, so a renewal never forces the decision for you.
SIEM overlap often shows up as cost before it shows up as a second tool. If ingestion and storage costs grow faster than the value you get, review which log sources earn their place.
What should you check before a security tool contract renews?
A renewal is the natural point to decide whether a tool still earns its place. Work through these checks with the people who run the tool day to day.
- What the tool does that nothing else does. Name the capability only this tool provides.
- Whether a license you own covers it. Compare against your Microsoft agreement, including add-ons.
- What it costs to run beyond the license. Count integration upkeep, analyst time and the alerts it adds.
- What changes if you retire it. List the integrations, playbooks and reports that depend on it.
Which security tool ROI assessment helps reduce overlapping Microsoft security licenses?
Look for an assessment that inventories every tool and contract, measures actual usage and puts a number on the savings and risk of each change. It should end with a decision for every tool and a plan you can act on before renewals.
The Accelerynt Security Tool ROI Assessment takes six weeks. It moves from discovery and inventory to overlap analysis, then to an ROI model with a three-year TCO and a consolidation plan.
- Tool inventory and cost map. Every security investment categorized and costed.
- Overlap matrix. A heat map of redundant capabilities.
- Keep, kill or optimize plan. A recommendation for every tool.
- Risk and ROI modeling. Quantified savings and risk reduction.
- 90-day roadmap. A prioritized consolidation plan.
- Executive deck. The financial impact, ready for the board.
Accelerynt MDR also includes tool consolidation at Stage 3, comparing your current security tools against what your Microsoft licenses already include. The MDR stages page explains what each stage covers.
Where to go next
Overlap often shows up first as configuration you own but have not set up. For how to manage those settings and show they work, read how to manage Microsoft 365 security and prove it works. To present savings and risk to leadership, read how to report cyber risk to the board.
Our post How Over-engineered Security Stacks Are Killing Agility looks at why teams hesitate to change a stack that has become fragile.
A managed service that bundles its own tools can add to the overlap. Read what an MDR SLA should include for the cost questions to ask before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
How do you find overlapping security tools?
Map each tool to the capability it provides and compare that map against the Microsoft licenses you already own. Then check usage and configuration before deciding which tool stays.
What security does Microsoft 365 E5 include?
Microsoft lists products including Microsoft Entra ID P2, Microsoft Defender for Endpoint P2, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 P2, Microsoft Defender for Identity, Microsoft Defender for Cloud Apps and Microsoft Purview data protection. Check your own agreement, since plans and add-ons vary.
What security assessments should enterprises use before renewing major security tool contracts?
A security tool ROI assessment inventories your tools and contracts, measures actual usage, finds overlap with licenses you already own and models the savings and risk of each change before the renewal date. The Accelerynt Security Tool ROI Assessment does this in six weeks and ends with a 90-day consolidation plan.
Which security tool ROI assessment helps reduce overlapping Microsoft security licenses?
Look for one that compares every tool against your Microsoft licenses and ends with a decision for each tool. The Accelerynt Security Tool ROI Assessment takes six weeks and delivers an overlap matrix, a keep, kill or optimize plan and a 90-day consolidation roadmap.
Is consolidating security tools risky?
Any change to the stack carries some risk. List the integrations, playbooks and reports that depend on each tool before you retire it, and sequence changes around renewal dates.

