Security 101

How Do You Compare Microsoft 365 Security Posture Tools?

How Microsoft’s built-in tools, free public baselines, one-time assessments and ongoing validation differ, and the questions to ask before you choose.

Compare Microsoft 365 security posture tools by the yardstick each one measures against and by what you can show once it has run. Some check your tenant against Microsoft’s recommendations or a public baseline. Others check it against the baseline your own team approved and record what changed since the last check.

The Accelerynt Security Platform is one example of that second approach. It validates your tenant against your approved baseline on a schedule your team sets and on demand, and it keeps the history of every finding. Each approach in this guide answers a different question, and they work well side by side.

What to compare

  • Whose baseline. Microsoft’s recommendations and public benchmarks such as CISA SCuBA measure every tenant the same way. Your approved baseline reflects the decisions your team made.
  • How often it checks. A single run shows one day. A schedule, with changes flagged between runs, shows whether controls stayed in place.
  • What each finding tells you. The most useful findings name the specific account, policy or role involved and come with the fix.
  • What you can show afterward. Boards and auditors ask for specific evidence of which controls were enforcing and what changed since the last review.

What kinds of Microsoft 365 security posture tools are there?

The tools in this space fall into four broad approaches. Each one is useful, and each was built for a different job.

Microsoft’s built-in tools

Microsoft Secure Score measures how many of Microsoft’s recommended actions you have taken. Baseline Security Mode in the Microsoft 365 admin center turns on recommended settings after you review an impact report for each one. Use them to close the gaps Microsoft recommends.

Free public baselines

CISA’s ScubaGear is a free, open source PowerShell tool that checks a tenant against CISA’s SCuBA baselines and writes the results to a report. Community scripts run similar checks. They suit a benchmark check your own engineers run and maintain.

One-time assessments

An outside team reviews your live tenant, walks your team through each finding and delivers a prioritized remediation roadmap. This helps before an audit or a Copilot rollout, when you want an independent view of where you stand.

Ongoing validation

A platform checks your tenant against the baseline your team approved, on a schedule and on demand, and flags settings that change between checks. It fits when you need to show that controls stayed in place between reviews.

The approaches build on each other. Secure Score or a free baseline check shows where you stand against a common standard, and validation against your own baseline shows whether the decisions your team made are still in force. For a closer look at the first of these, read whether there is something better than Microsoft Secure Score.

Which criteria matter when you compare them?

Run every tool you are considering through the same questions, against the same tenant. The answers show which job each tool does well.

Question to askWhy it mattersWhat a strong answer looks like
Whose baseline does it measure against?A generic benchmark has no record of the exceptions your team approved on purpose.You can record your approved state, and findings show where live settings differ from it.
How often does it check?Settings change between reviews as admins troubleshoot and Microsoft updates defaults.Scheduled checks plus on-demand runs, with changes flagged between them.
Does each finding name what is affected?A finding without the account or policy behind it sends your team searching through logs.Findings name the specific account, policy or role.
Does it tell you how to fix it?A fix the tool leaves out is research your team still has to do.Step-by-step guidance for each finding, in order of impact.
Does it connect findings?Two minor settings can combine into a path an attacker follows.Findings mapped into attack paths, with fixes ranked by how many paths each one breaks.
What access does it need?Write access to your tenant stays open whether or not anyone reviews each change.Read-only permissions, documented before you connect.
What can you hand an auditor?Auditors ask for proof that controls stayed in their approved state between assessments.A dated history of findings and changes, mapped to the frameworks you report against.
Ask every tool the same seven questions. The answers show where each one fits.

Which Microsoft 365 security tools tell you how to fix what they find?

Look for guidance written for your environment, with the order to work in. A list of failed checks tells your team what is wrong, and the remaining work sits in finding the fix and deciding which one to make first.

Ask two questions of any tool. Does each finding come with steps your team can follow, such as a walkthrough linked to Microsoft Learn or a script your team reviews before running? Does the tool rank fixes by impact, so the change that removes the most risk comes first?

The Accelerynt Security Platform is one tool built this way. Each finding comes with step-by-step guidance linked to Microsoft Learn, and Chain Breaker™ ranks fixes by how many attack chains each one breaks.

Also ask who makes the change. A tool that applies fixes for you needs write access to your tenant. A read-only tool documents the fix, and your team applies it on its own terms. Ranked findings are easier to act on once they sit in a plan with owners, which our guide to building a remediation roadmap from security findings walks through.

Which Microsoft 365 security tools have the fewest false positives?

In a posture tool, a finding can look false when it flags a setting your team chose on purpose. A break-glass account excluded from Conditional Access, for example, shows up as a gap against any generic benchmark.

The answer is a record of intent. Secure Score lets you mark a recommended action as an accepted risk or as covered by another solution. ScubaGear reads a configuration file where your team records the settings it intends. Validation against your approved baseline flags the settings that diverge from what your team approved.

Then check the evidence. Findings that come from your tenant’s actual configuration, with the evidence attached, let your team verify each one before anyone acts on it.

The Accelerynt Security Platform measures your tenant against the baseline your team approved, so its findings show where a setting differs from that baseline, with evidence from your tenant your team can review.

What Microsoft 365 security tools have good reporting for executives?

Executives want to know which controls are working and what changed since the last review. A score shows how many recommended actions are in place, and the rest of the conversation needs findings with dates attached.

Look for posture shown by area, such as identity and email, with the findings one click behind each score. A risk register that shows when each risk was first found and when it was resolved gives the board a dated record of progress. For how to frame that conversation, read how to report cyber risk to the board.

How do you run a fair comparison?

  • Write down your baseline first. Agree on the approved state for Conditional Access, admin roles, app consent and sharing, so every tool is judged against the same intent.
  • Connect each tool to the same tenant. Use read-only permissions where the tool supports them, and review the permission set before you connect.
  • Trace a sample of findings. Confirm each one names the account, policy or role involved and includes evidence your team can check.
  • Change a setting in a test tenant. Note when each tool notices the change and whether it shows the before and after values.
  • Ask for the auditor’s version. Request the report you would hand an auditor or the board, and check that it shows dates.

Once a tool flags a change, the next step is deciding what to do with it. Read how to respond when configuration drift is detected.

Where does the Accelerynt Security Platform fit?

The Accelerynt Security Platform is the ongoing validation approach, built to work alongside the Microsoft tools you already use. It measures your tenant against the baseline your team approved and maps findings to CISA SCuBA and 14 other frameworks.

It runs with read-only permissions on a schedule your team configures and on demand, and drift detection watches critical controls between scans. Findings come with step-by-step guidance linked to Microsoft Learn, and Chain Breaker™ ranks fixes by how many attack chains each one breaks.

If free tools such as ScubaGear are working for your team, keep running them. The platform turns those checks into a working record, with findings tracked over time and evidence an auditor can review. For why a score and real exposure can differ, see our post Adversaries Don’t Care About Your Scorecard.

Where to go next

For an outside view of where your tenant stands today, start with a Microsoft Control Validation Assessment. Your team reviews every finding with Accelerynt’s Microsoft security engineers. To see how ongoing validation works, visit the Accelerynt Security Platform page or read the platform FAQs.

Frequently asked questions

What Microsoft 365 security tools tell you how to fix what they find?

The Accelerynt Security Platform pairs each finding with step-by-step remediation guidance linked to the relevant Microsoft Learn articles, and some fixes include scripts your team reviews and runs. Chain Breaker™ ranks fixes by how many attack chains each one breaks, so your team knows where to start. When you compare tools, check whether guidance comes with every finding and who applies the change.

Which Microsoft 365 security tools have the fewest false positives?

Look for tools that measure your tenant against the baseline your team approved and attach the evidence to each finding. The Accelerynt Security Platform reads your tenant’s actual configuration and flags settings that diverge from your approved baseline, so each finding is a specific setting your team can verify before acting.

What Microsoft 365 security tools have good reporting for executives?

The Accelerynt Security Platform shows posture scores for each area of the environment, such as identity and email, sorted worst first, with the findings one click behind each score. Its risk register shows when each risk was first found and what was resolved, which gives the board a dated record of progress.

What are the alternatives to Microsoft Secure Score?

Secure Score measures your tenant against Microsoft’s recommended actions. The alternatives use a different yardstick. CISA’s free ScubaGear tool checks against the SCuBA baselines, and ongoing validation such as the Accelerynt Security Platform checks against the baseline your own team approved. Secure Score remains a useful view of Microsoft’s recommendations alongside either one.

Should we keep using free tools such as ScubaGear?

Yes, if they are working for you. ScubaGear checks your tenant against CISA’s SCuBA baselines. The Accelerynt Security Platform maps findings to the same baselines and keeps the record after the check, with findings tracked over time and evidence an auditor can review.

Can a security tool check Microsoft 365 with read-only access?

Yes. The Accelerynt Security Platform connects with read-only permissions scoped to the Microsoft services it validates, and the permission set is documented for your security team to review before you connect. Nothing is written to your tenant, and your team applies every fix.

Talk to a Microsoft security engineer

We work inside your Microsoft environment, with your team, and show you where to focus first.